this is mikel.org

Michael Boyle's weblog

  • home
  • archives
  • about
  • words

Tom Coates:

April 29, 2005 by Michael Boyle

Tom Coates:

Trackback is dead. Are Comments dead too?. It’s funny – I read this the other day and largely agreed with Tom – I turned trackbacks off long ago. At the same time, I know of at least one implementation of trackback – YULBlog, by Patrick Tanguay, that is very useful and easy to use. But then I read a post that Patrick wrote (the day before Tom’s post, incidentally) about problems that have crept in to that implementation as well – which led someone (who wasn’t really clear on the whole concept of tb) to “leave” YULBlog.

The problem with trackback, though, is also its strength. I can think of wonderful implementations of the trackback concept that take things like a blogroll, contacts/friends from Flickr, and other such data as a sort of whitelist that would indicate to a publishing system that a particular trackback ping does in fact come from a qualified individual. But trackbacks from people that a blogger already reads – and has to some extent publicly announced that he/she reads or knows – is a pretty thin concept. I get a much bigger kick out of knowing that someone I don’t already know has enjoyed a post enough to link to it. So it’s a seemingly insurmountable problem – trackback could be workable within a smaller, self-identified community – but that’s also the kind of environment in which it’s less useful, and in fact could serve to heighten the “echo-chamber” effect that does seem to affect the weblog space to some extent.

Tags: Blogging

search

recent

  • Diouf Article
  • Anil Dash: We’re not being alarmist enough about climate change…
  • Learning about Gutenberg
  • From the “I thought I’d heard it all” file
  • One year since his passing: The Day Prince’s Guitar Wept the Loudest

Archives

War Browser Canadian Politics Design Web Design Google Music Microsoft Test Software Personal Internet Email Business Copyfight Wired Montreal US Politics Search Media Arts Friend International Affairs Social Networks Sports NYTimes Web Apple Blogging GNE Funny Canada
Michael Boyle Blog
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2000–2025 · Michael Boyle

Copyright © 2025 · Modern Portfolio Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in