Why Puretracks will fail

In Canada we can’t yet use the iTunes Music Store, which is bad enough, the only legal download site is called Puretracks. Trouble is, when I go to the site I get the following message:

Thank you for visiting Puretracks.com
Currently our website supports Internet Explorer 5.0 and above on the
Windows operating system (Win 98SE / ME / 2000 / XP / 2003),
and is available to Canadian residents only.
We value our Mac audience, however the Windows Media player for the Mac
platform is not currently compatible with Microsoft protected audio content.
Puretracks is currently working to make our service available to Mac users.

There are several problems with this. First of all, saying you value an audience while locking them out is NOT valuing that audience. More importantly, though, I think the companies trying to make a go of online music that tie that effort to a proprietary platform are making a big mistake and can’t, in the long term, succeed with such a strategy. The encoding method used by Apple, on the other hand, is available to anyone who wishes to use it, with no approval or license required from Apple. Tying DRM to the encoding itself is a serious conceptual mistake that a lot of people are making, and no matter how many companies signed up to play in the Microsoft sandbox I don’t think they can do well.

3 comments ↓

#1 Zeke on 02.02.04 at 1:44 pm

Howdy!

Being a bloke in Quebec seems to be like being a Mac user in a corporate world.

I’ve never heard of Puretracks, But Archambault launched with great fanfare Archambaultzik.ca

http://www.archambaultzik.ca

And although I have never used it, my guess is that with that “.ca” it will work in Canada.

My question about all of these ways to “legally” d/l songs, is how much cash actually gets into the musicians pocket, versus all of the middlemen’s?

Play ball!

#2 Michael on 02.02.04 at 1:47 pm

I suspect very little, though I hope that will change, obviously.

#3 Michael on 02.02.04 at 1:48 pm

Alas Archambault doesn’t support macs either. Only WMP 9 or whatever.

About mikel.org

This is mikel.org, a weblog that has been published by Michael Boyle since January, 2000.

Links

Community

Friends etc.

Tag Cloud

Some Rights Reserved

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Canada Licence.

Add to Technorati Favorites

Subscribe to mikel.org's syndication feed.
 Atom feed

YULBlog